ON THIS DAY : 1965
Studio 2. 2.30-5.30pm. Recording: ‘It’s Only Love’ (takes 1-6).
Producer: George Martin; Engineer: Norman Smith; 2nd Engineer: Phil McDonald.
“It’s Only Love” is a song written mostly by John Lennon and credited to Lennon–McCartney. It was first released in 1965 on the Help! album in the United Kingdom and on the Rubber Soul album in the United States.
The Beatles recorded “It’s Only Love” at EMI Studios in London on 15 June 1965. Lennon’s working title for the composition was “That’s a Nice Hat”. The band recorded six takes of the rhythm track, two of which were incomplete, with a line-up of 6- and 12-string acoustic guitars, bass and drums. The high register of the acoustic guitars was created through Lennon and George Harrison each using a capo on the neck of their instrument.
Lennon overdubbed his vocals onto the final take, and Harrison recorded lead guitar parts, including one with a heavy tremolo effect. According to musicologist Walter Everett’s description of the recording, Harrison played all three of the electric guitar parts, including one that doubles the main riff on a Rickenbacker 12-string.
Author Ian MacDonald cites the varied sound treatment applied to Lennon’s vocals and Harrison’s guitars as an example of the Beatles’ increasingly experimental approach to production during the Help! period.
Take 2 of “It’s Only Love” was included on the Anthology 2 compilation in 1996, with a false start (the incomplete take 3) edited onto the beginning of the track.
John Lennon was highly critical of “It’s Only Love”, describing it as a “lousy song” with “abysmal lyrics”. In MacDonald’s opinion, the song is a “twee make-weight” that, while “slightly redeemed by the vigorous chorus”, features the “hollowest” lyrics of John Lennon’s career.
Journalist Mark Hertsgaard says that although the song falls short of the high standard of John Lennon’s Help! track “You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away”, his dismissal of “It’s Only Love” was overly harsh and fails to do justice to its “lovely lilting melody”. In his review of Help! for AllMusic, Stephen Thomas Erlewine considers “It’s Only Love” to be one of the rare “minor numbers” on an album where John Lennon dominates the songwriting with “great” contributions such as “Ticket to Ride”, the title track and “You’re Going To Lose That Girl”.
According to Ian MacDonald :
John Lennon – double-tracked lead vocal, 12-string acoustic guitar
Paul McCartney – bass guitar
George Harrison – acoustic guitar, lead guitars
Ringo Starr – drums, tambourine